If I had to pick one watch part even the most inexperienced buyer should have knowledge about, then I would definitely point to the movement of the watch. It’s the heart of every timepiece and as we know, once the heart stops, so does the rest. After reading this article, you will be able to differentiate between the three primary watch movement types and pick one that fits you best.
Movement, also often referred to as “caliber”, is the mechanism that drives the watch hands. It’s also behind any other watch feature you can think of, such as timer, alarm or calendar. It’s basically what makes the watch tick.
Some brands have their own proprietary movement technologies and there hundreds of watch movement manufacturers in the world. Still, at the end of the day, it all comes down to just three watch mechanism types: mechanical, automatic and quartz.
Each has its individual style as well as its own list of positives and negatives. At the end of the day, different people will go for different mechanisms based on their own preferences and needs. Hence, it’s extremely important to be able to distinguish between them and pick accordingly. Find all three watch movement types explained below.
Mechanical Watch Movement
Looking chronologically, the mechanical movement was the first to see daylight. It was the movement on which the first watch in the world operated and it’s been with us for centuries now.
There are two mechanical watch movement types: manually-wound and automatic (which I will discuss in detail later).
The first type of mechanical watches, as the name suggests, need to be wound in order to run. Manually-wound watches are powered by the so-called “mainspring”. Once the spring is wound, it starts unwinding itself gradually. As a result, it starts driving all the gears responsible for the watch hands movement, as well as other complications.
It’s only fair to mention that this type of watch movement is the most time-consuming. For the watch to show the correct time, you will have to regularly dedicate a couple of minutes to wind it. Usually, a few turns of the crown will be enough to fully wind the spring and store the energy needed to work the mechanisms.
The power reserve in manual mechanical watches will differ, depending on the brand of the timepiece and the model. At the very least, it should be enough to fuel the watch for 24 hours. At the other end of the scale, there are some manually-wound watches that will run for a full week.
Most people who own mechanical watches, don’t really care how often they need to wind them. Many of manually-wound watch owners are collectors, true watch dorks. For them, the whole process of playing with the intricate mechanism of such a watch is the reason why they bought it in the first place.
Even though the mechanical movement type is the oldest, watches that use it are often more expensive than quartz timepieces. The reason is simple: the number of hours a watchmaker has to dedicate to create a top-quality, manually-wound timepiece is just so much bigger.
More often than not, the material of which the watch parts are made is also of higher quality. Once you start browsing for manually-wound timepieces, you will notice that many of them come with beautifully-presented, transparent case backs through which you can watch admire all the intricate mechanisms.
Automatic Watch Movement
Next on the line are automatic watches. Some consider(ed) them to be an upgrade on the manually-wound timepieces but I’m pretty sure many of the retro style enthusiasts will beg to differ on this one.
To put it very shortly, the automatic watch movement functions nearly identically to its predecessor. The only difference is that you won’t have to wind it so often – or not at all. Automatic watches are frequently referred to as self-winding because they wind themselves without you having to tinker with the crown.
How does the magic happen, then? Unlike manually-wound timepieces, watches with the automatic movement include a rotor. Putting it into the simplest terms possible, a rotor is an additional metal weight connected to the movement’s mechanism. When wearing the watch, your wrist moves, causing the rotor to twirl and transfer the energy necessary to wind the mainspring. Voila!
Even though the need to wind an automatic watch is nowhere near as frequent as a manually-wound one, you will still have to do it from time to time. As soon as you take the timepiece off your wrist, it will slowly start unwinding. After a short period of time, the accuracy will drop whereas with an extended break in wearing, it will come to a halt altogether. Worry not, the process of winding is just as smooth as in the case of the previous movement type.
If you have more than one automatic watch and you don’t want to wind it every time you put it on, then consider buying a watch winder. It’s a great device that mimics the wrist movement, keeping your watch running all the time.
When you look at the design of automatic watches, many are just as elegant and elaborate as those that need manual winding. More often than not, they also will cost you more than a standard quartz watch. In fact, when you look at the luxury brands like Rolex, Omega or Tag Hauer, most of these watches are “automatics”. If that’s asking a bit too much of your budget, then consider cheaper automatic brands like Bulova or Tissot.
Quartz Watch Movement
The freshest of them all. The introduction of the first Quartz watch by a Japanese conglomerate Seiko sparked the so-called Quartz Crisis. Also referred to as the Quartz Revolution, it was a period of turmoil for most of the watchmaking brands caused by the arrival of the first quartz timepieces.
At that time, the advent of new technology noticeably decreased the need for mechanical and automatic watches. As of today, quartz movement models are still the most-sold from all three. Over the last decade, though, a growing number of people seem to be appreciating the more complex mechanisms of mechanical timepieces.
Since the previous movement types relied on mechanical movement, it’s not hard to guess that quartz watches are battery-powered. The power in quartz timepieces is created by a battery that sends an electrical stream through a quartz crystal. As a consequence, the crystal is able to create vibrations which in turn keep the movement going.
Because they are battery-run, quartz watches require very little-to-zero maintenance over the years. At the same time, they are also much more accurate as they don’t rely on any outside force for the movement to run. In fact, some of the more premium models can boast an accuracy of just a few seconds a year.
Some quartz watches don’t need batteries. Many leading brands in the watchmaking industry, like Citizen or Casio, have developed lines of watches that are solar-powered.
Even though there’s no doubt that quartz watches are much more precise, cheaper and require less maintenance, they often lack the intricate craftsmanship and beauty so characteristic of mechanical timepieces. And this is probably the reason why they’ve been enjoying a true renaissance in the last decade or so.
Different Types of Watch Movements: Conclusion + FAQ
Since now you know about the main three types of watch mechanisms, as well as their good and bad sides, making the right choice should be easy. There are no good and bad mechanisms – all watch movement types have their pros and cons. At the end of the day, it’s up to you to pick the one that suits your needs best.
To squeeze as much information out of this article as possible, I have also collected the most frequently asked questions related to the topic. You can find them answered below.
What is the best watch movement type?
It’s really hard to tell which watch movement is best as it will purely depend on what you prioritize in timepieces.
If you want a watch that’s as hassle-free to use as possible, then the natural choice would be a quartz timepiece. These watches should also be seriously considered by people that value accuracy.
If you are after a more sophisticated look and intricate mechanisms that don’t need frequent winding, then automatic watches will serve you well.
Should you belong to the group of watch enthusiasts longing for the most retro-style timepieces, then manually-wound mechanical watches are the obvious pick. Highly recommended especially for people who love the ritual of winding the timepiece.
What is the smoothest movement?
If by smoothest you mean the way the watch hands move, then it’s safe to say mechanical watches, whether manually-wound or automatic, are your best bet.
When you look at the second hand of any mechanical watch, it runs in a smooth, sweeping motion. Quartz watches, on the other hand, use the so-called “tick-tock” motion. This is clearly shown here.
Is it possible to replace a watch movement?
Absolutely. If it happens that any of the movement types wear off or simply break down, replacing it with the same type won’t be a problem. Actually, in some instances, it’s possible to interchange the movements, allowing you to replace a quartz movement with a mechanical one and vice versa.
Even though there are tons of tutorial videos on the subject on the web, the safest option would be to bring your watch to a certified watchmaker. Depending on the complexity of the movement, replacement cost may vary between $25 to $100.
Swiss or Japanese quartz movement?
Japanese company Seiko are the pioneers of the quartz movement and as of today, they are still one of the global leaders when it comes to battery-powered watches.
Whereas mechanical Swiss watch movements are by far the best in the business in their own field, it’s only fair to admit that, as far as quartz watches are concerned, Japanese movements seem to offer more.
One of the biggest advantages they hold over Swiss quartz movements is that many of them are radio-controlled, offering atomic timekeeping with even greater accuracy. Many of the Japanese quartz watches are also solar-powered. Last but not least, some of the models are “kinetic” (using rotor power similar to automatic watches).